Demand–Control Model

Strain builds when a job asks a lot of you and gives you little say.

What is the Demand–Control Model?

In 1979, the researcher Robert Karasek suggested that two things shape how stressful a job feels:

  • Demands: how much the job asks of you. Workload, time pressure, conflicting priorities and how hard you have to concentrate.
  • Control: how much say you have. Choosing how, when and in what order you do the work, and getting to use and build your skills.

Karasek's insight was that these two things need to be looked at together. A heavy workload feels very different depending on how much freedom you have to handle it.

The four types of job

Putting demands and control together gives four broad types of job:

Low demands, plenty of controlLow strainLow demands, plenty of control. Comfortable and relaxed.
High demands, plenty of controlActiveHigh demands, plenty of control. Busy and challenging, but often energising, because you can shape how the work gets done.
Low demands, little controlPassiveLow demands, little control. Not stressful in the usual sense, but can lead to boredom and losing skills.
High demands, little controlHigh strainHigh demands, little control. The most draining combination. Lots to do and little say over how.

Researchers later added a third factor: support. Help and backing from colleagues and managers also makes demanding work easier to carry.

Why organisations end up here

Organisations rarely set out to create high-strain jobs. It tends to happen because decisions get made in different places.

Workloads and deadlines are often set by one group, such as senior leaders, clients or another department. Decisions about how the work is done, such as processes, tools and approval steps, are set by another. The people doing the work end up with the pressure but none of the say.

Rules and processes often build up for good reasons, such as consistency, safety or compliance. But each one takes away a little control, and the effect adds up.

What the research found

It's one of the most studied ideas about stress at work. A review of 83 studies found that demands and control each affect wellbeing: more demands make things worse, and more control makes things better.

Karasek also suggested that control would cancel out high demands, so that a busy job with lots of freedom would feel fine. The review found very little evidence for that. A bit more say can help, but it's unlikely to make an impossible workload fine.

How it plays out at work

You have twelve priorities, a deadline set by someone you've never met and a process you aren't allowed to change. When you mention it, you're told to try better time management.

The job is asking a lot and giving you very little room to decide how to deliver it. Better time management can only go so far.

Signs a job is high strain

  • Work arrives faster than you can finish it, with no say over priorities.
  • Processes or tools slow you down, but you can't change them.
  • Decisions about your work are made without asking you.
  • You feel tired and tense, even on days that aren't especially busy.
  • Breaks, holidays or flexibility feel hard to take.

What helps

  1. Find one thing you control. Look at the order, method or timing of your work. Even a small area of choice can ease the strain a little, and it gives you a base to ask for more.
  2. Raise the workload itself. Asking “Which of these should stop?” or “Which matters most this week?” puts the focus back on the demands, which is where the bigger problem usually sits.

Common questions

What is the Demand–Control Model?

It's a way of understanding work stress, developed by Robert Karasek in 1979. It says that jobs with high demands and little control are the most draining.

Does having more control reduce stress?

More control generally helps wellbeing, but research finds it rarely cancels out very high demands. Reducing the workload matters too.

Why is my job so stressful when I'm not even that busy?

Low control can be draining on its own. Having no say over how, when or what you do can wear you down, even when the workload is manageable.

Sources

Related