Bikeshedding
Law of Triviality
People spend the most time on small things they understand, and rush the big ones.
What is bikeshedding?
In 1957, the historian C. Northcote Parkinson described an imaginary finance committee with three items on its agenda:
| Item | Cost | Time spent |
|---|---|---|
| Nuclear reactor | £10 million | Two and a half minutes |
| Bicycle shed for staff | £350 | Around 45 minutes |
| Refreshments | £21 a year | Over an hour |
The committee approved the reactor in two and a half minutes. It spent around 45 minutes arguing about the bike shed, and over an hour on the refreshments.
Parkinson called this the Law of Triviality: the time spent on an item tends to be in inverse proportion to the money involved. Decades later, software developers picked up the idea and gave it a catchier name, “bikeshedding”. It's now used for any discussion that gets stuck on small, easy details while the big, hard questions slip through.
Why it happens
Parkinson's explanation was simple. Everyone can picture a bike shed, so everyone has an opinion and feels qualified to give it. A reactor is complicated, so few people feel able to challenge it. They assume the experts have it covered.
There are other reasons too:
- Small things feel safe. Commenting on a colour or a heading carries little risk. Questioning a big plan can feel exposing, especially if you're not sure you understand it.
- People want to contribute. In a meeting, saying something shows you're engaged. The easiest things to comment on are the ones everyone can see.
- Big decisions are tiring. They involve uncertainty and trade-offs. It's natural to put them off and spend energy where progress feels easier.
- Time runs out. Agendas often put the easy items first. By the time the important item comes up, people are tired and ready to leave.
What the research found
The idea started as satire and has been tested very little directly. One related experiment in 2021 found that people gathered too much information before small decisions and too little before big ones, which fits the pattern. The researchers suggested people find it hard to judge when they know enough, and feel more confident weighing up things they understand.
Treat bikeshedding as a useful label for something many people recognise. The evidence behind it is thin.
How it plays out at work
A project review is booked for an hour. Forty minutes go on the colours in the slides and the wording of one heading. The hiring plan, which commits most of next year's budget, is approved in the last five minutes as people start to leave.
Afterwards, the person who chaired the meeting feels it went well. Lots of people spoke and decisions were made.
Other signs you might notice
- Lots of comments on wording, formatting or layout, and few on the substance.
- Big decisions approved quickly with little challenge.
- Long email threads about minor details.
- Someone who usually stays quiet on strategy has strong views on presentation.
Could this be you?
Think about the last document you reviewed. Did your comments focus on the parts you understood best, or the parts that mattered most? Most people find it easier to tidy a sentence than to question a plan. Noticing that is the first step to spending your attention where it counts.
When it might be something else
Sometimes small details really matter. A typo in a contract, a confusing heading in a customer email or a wrong number on a slide can cause real problems. And sometimes a big decision is waved through quickly because it was properly discussed elsewhere. It's worth checking before assuming the balance is off.
What helps
- Ask: “Which of these decisions would be hardest to undo?” Then suggest those go first on the agenda, while people are fresh.
- Ask yourself: “Am I commenting on this because it matters, or because it's the part I understand?” If someone else keeps getting stuck on details, they may not feel equipped to engage with the bigger issue. A short, plain explanation of the big item can help them join in.
Common questions
Why does my manager focus on tiny details?
Small details are easy for everyone to understand and comment on. Bigger, more complex issues feel harder to question, so attention drifts to what feels manageable.
Where does the term bikeshedding come from?
From C. Northcote Parkinson's 1957 example of a committee that spent minutes on a nuclear reactor and much longer on a bike shed. Software developers popularised the word “bikeshedding” in the late 1990s.
Is bikeshedding backed by research?
Only loosely. It began as satire, and one related experiment found people over-think small decisions and under-think big ones. It's best used as a helpful label.