Leader–Member Exchange

In-groups and out-groups

People with limited time build closer working relationships with a few colleagues, often very early on.

What is Leader–Member Exchange?

Anyone in charge of a group has a limited amount of time and attention. Instead of sharing it out evenly, people tend to build a few close, trusting working relationships and keep the rest more formal. Researchers call these the “in-group” and the “out-group”.

People in the in-group get more information, more interesting work and more benefit of the doubt. They hear about changes early and get asked for their opinion. People in the out-group get clear instructions and not much else. The relationship is about getting the job done, with little trust or give and take.

The name, Leader–Member Exchange, reflects the idea that each relationship is a two-way exchange. Each pair builds its own relationship, and no two are quite the same.

Why it happens

Usually this happens without anyone planning it. People lean on colleagues they already trust because it feels quicker and safer, especially under pressure.

These relationships often form in the first few weeks, based on things like:

  • Early impressions. A good first piece of work, or a confident first meeting.
  • Being nearby. Who happened to sit close by, or was on the same calls.
  • Feeling similar. Shared background, interests or ways of working.
  • Timing. Who was around when something urgent needed doing.

Once formed, the relationships tend to stick. Researchers describe them as moving from “strangers” to “acquaintances” and then, for some, to a “mature partnership”. Being in the in-group brings chances to shine, which makes in-group members look better still. Being in the out-group means fewer chances, which can look like a lack of ability. Over time, the gap can grow into something that looks like favouritism.

What the research found

Researchers have studied this since the 1970s. A review of 247 studies found that people with stronger relationships with the person in charge tended to be more satisfied, more committed, rated as better performers and less likely to want to leave.

The same review found that the leader's own behaviour and expectations explained more about the quality of the relationship than anything about the employee. If you feel on the outside, that probably says more about early circumstances than about your worth.

Another large review, covering 253 studies in 23 countries, found these links were generally stronger in Western countries than in many Asian ones, so culture plays a part too.

There are limits. Most of the research shows links rather than proving cause and effect. Some researchers argue the theory describes good relationships better than it explains how to build them.

How it plays out at work

A new team lead joins. In the first week, two people happen to sit near them and help them find their feet. A few months later, those two get pulled into planning chats and hear about changes first.

Priya hears about decisions second-hand. When she suggests an idea in a meeting, the answer is usually “let's park that for now”. The gap opened in week one, over something as small as where people sat, and nobody noticed it growing.

Other signs you might notice

  • The same few people are always consulted before decisions are made.
  • Some people get stretch projects, while others get routine work.
  • Mistakes are forgiven for some people and picked over for others.
  • Informal chats, lunches or messages happen with some team members and not others.
  • You find out about changes after colleagues do.

Could this be you?

If you lead people, or even just a project, it's worth noticing who you go to first when something comes up, and who you haven't spoken to properly in a while. Most people have an in-group without realising it. Spreading your time a little more evenly can make a big difference to the people on the edges.

When it might be something else

Sometimes people are given different work for good reasons, such as experience, skills or workload. And sometimes someone keeps everyone at a distance, including you. It helps to look at the pattern across the whole team before deciding it's personal.

What helps

  1. Ask yourself: “When did the gap open up, and what was going on then?” It often comes down to timing and circumstance, which can make it feel less personal and easier to change.
  2. Ask for a regular, short check-in. A fifteen-minute slot every week or two gives the relationship time to grow. You could open with: “What's most useful for you to hear from me?”

Common questions

Why does my manager have favourites?

People in charge have limited time, so they tend to build closer working relationships with a few people, often in the first weeks. It usually happens without anyone deciding it, and it tends to grow over time.

Is being in the out-group my fault?

Not usually. Research suggests the leader's own behaviour explains more about the relationship than anything about the employee. Early timing and circumstance play a big part.

Can you move from the out-group to the in-group?

Relationships can change, especially with regular contact and a chance to show what you can do. It's slower once patterns are set, so small, steady steps tend to work better than one big push.

Sources

Related