Peter Principle

People get promoted for doing their current job well, even when the next job needs different skills.

What is the Peter Principle?

In 1969, Laurence Peter and Raymond Hull wrote a half-joking book with a serious point. They put it like this: in a hierarchy, every employee tends to rise to their level of incompetence.

Their argument was simple. People who do their job well get promoted. If they do the new job well, they get promoted again. This carries on until they reach a job they can't do well. At that point the promotions stop, and they stay there.

The joke has lasted for more than fifty years because so many people recognise it. Most of us have worked with someone who was brilliant in one role and then seemed lost in the next.

Why it happens

Organisations promote people based on what they can see, and the easiest thing to see is how well someone does their current job. The top salesperson, the best engineer or the most reliable nurse is the obvious choice when a team lead role opens up.

The trouble is that leading people is a different job. It's about coaching, delegating, planning, sharing information and having difficult conversations. Being excellent at the work itself doesn't prepare you for any of that, and most people get very little training when they step up.

There are other pressures too:

  • Promotion is often the only reward on offer. In many organisations, the only way to earn more or be recognised is to move into management, even for people who would rather stay hands-on.
  • Saying no feels risky. Turning down a promotion can look like a lack of ambition, so people accept roles they aren't sure about.
  • Old strengths become habits. Under pressure, people fall back on what has always worked for them. For a former expert, that means doing the work themselves.

The person is being judged in a job they were never really tested for.

What the research found

For decades, the Peter Principle was mostly an observation. Then a team of economists tested it using real performance data from sales staff at well over 100 US companies.

They found that the best sellers were the most likely to be promoted into management. Yet their teams tended to do worse afterwards. Each time a new manager's past sales doubled, their team's sales fell by about 7.5%.

The researchers also found that people who had shown they could work well with others made better managers, even when their own sales figures were less impressive. In other words, the skills that predicted good management were different from the ones that got people promoted.

The study only looked at sales, where performance is easy to measure, so it can't tell us how widely the pattern holds. But it gives real weight to an idea that started as a joke.

How it plays out at work

Sam was the best analyst on the team, so when the team lead left, Sam got the job. Six months on, Sam rewrites everyone's reports late at night instead of giving feedback. One-to-ones get cancelled when things are busy, which is always. In meetings, Sam dives into the detail of a spreadsheet while bigger decisions wait.

The team has gained a very good analyst and lost a manager. Sam is working harder than ever and can't understand why things feel worse.

Other signs you might notice

  • They are still the go-to person for the hardest technical problems, even ones their team could handle.
  • They give detailed corrections, but little sense of direction or priorities.
  • Difficult conversations, such as poor performance or conflict, get put off.
  • They seem more comfortable with the work than with the people doing it.
  • They are visibly stretched, but reluctant to hand things over.

Could this be you?

If you've recently stepped up, it's worth asking yourself a few honest questions. When something goes wrong, do you fix it yourself or help someone else fix it? Do you know what each person on your team is aiming for? Have you had any real training in your new role? Struggling in a new job is normal. Noticing it early makes it much easier to change.

When it might be something else

Someone can seem out of their depth for other reasons. They may have been given too much to do, too little support or unclear goals from above. They may be dealing with something outside work. The Peter Principle is one possible explanation, and it's worth holding it lightly until you know more.

What helps

  1. Ask yourself: “Is this person bad at their job, or new at a different job?” Seeing them as someone still learning a new role can make their behaviour easier to accept, and easier to talk about without it feeling like a criticism.
  2. Go to them for what they're good at. Their expertise is probably why they were promoted, so bring them the hard technical problems. Look elsewhere, such as a mentor or a more experienced colleague, for coaching and career advice.

Common questions

Why does my manager seem out of their depth?

Often because they were promoted for being excellent at a different job. Leading people needs skills that their old role never tested, and many new managers get little training.

Is the Peter Principle real?

It started as satire, but a large study of sales staff found that top performers were more likely to be promoted and their teams tended to do worse. The evidence comes from one type of job, so treat it as a real pattern with limited evidence.

Can someone grow out of it?

Yes. Many people struggle in their first leadership role and get better with time, feedback and support. The pattern describes where many people start, and most can move on from it.

Sources

Related